Joaquin Phoenix Sheriff Joe Cross Pedro Pascal Mayor Ted Garcia Luke Grimes Deputy Guy Tooley Deirdre O'Connell Dawn Bodkin Micheal Ward Deputy Michael Cooke Emma Stone Louise Cross Austin Butler Vernon Jefferson Peak Cameron Mann Brian Frazee Matt Gomez Hidaka Eric Garcia Amélie Hoeferle Sarah Allen Clifton Collins Jr. Lodge William Belleau Officer Butterfly Jimenez Landall Goolsby Will Elise Falanga Nicolette King Orba Warren Rachel de la Torre Paula David Pinter ANTIFA Terrorist #1 Keith Jardine ANTIFA Terrorist #2 David Midthunder Santa Lupe Pueblo Sheriff Christine Hughes Tina William Sterchi John James Cady Fred / Old Man Thom Rivera Grocery Store Owner Mickey Bond Elderly Woman Manny Rubio Employee -- Grocery Store Vic Browder Phil -- Council Member Diane Villegas Council Member -- Zoom Kristin K. Berg Tam